Alec and Hilaria Baldwin List Their $19 Million Hamptons Mansion for a 5th Time—as New Agent Touts Its Historic Connections to Marilyn Monroe
Alec and Hilaria Baldwin’s expansive Hamptons estate is back on the market for a fifth time, complete with fresh new photos—and surprising new insight about the property’s somewhat tenuous connection to movie star, Marilyn Monroe.
The five-bedroom, 6.5-bathroom property, which was taken off the market on July 8 following multiple price decreases, has now returned with the same lowered ask of $18.99 million.
Known as Stony Hill Farm, the estate features a picturesque primary residence that spans 8,556 square feet and sits on a 5.06-acre property, overlooking an additional 3.22 acres of agricultural reserve.
The dwelling has been on quite the adventure since the couple made their first attempt at selling it for $29 million in 2022, nearly 30 years after Baldwin purchased it for just $1.75 million.
In the past four years, the duo have slashed their asking price repeatedly, while bouncing the dwelling on and off the market multiple times—at one point even claiming that they had changed their minds about selling it altogether.
This time around, the Baldwins have enlisted a new agent and team to help them market the property—Lori Schiaffino and The Schiaffino Team at Compass—who have already begun touting the mansion's intriguing ties to actress Monroe and her husband, Arthur Miller, in a bid to draw in a buyer.
“In the summers of 1957 and 1958, Marilyn Monroe and Arthur Miller spent their days in the pastoral landscape surrounding Stony Hill Farm, with their nearby farmhouse reportedly overlooking what is now this Amagansett estate,” the caption reads on an Instagram post shared on The Schiaffino Team's account.
“The natural beauty of this private corner of Amagansett has long attracted artists, writers, and public figures,” it continues.
“Rich in history, surrounded by protected landscapes, and just minutes from Atlantic Avenue and Indian Wells beaches, Stony Hill Farm presents a rare opportunity to own an estate where Amagansett’s agricultural roots meet the ease of coastal living.”
Schiaffino did not respond to requests for comment.
The property’s return to the market is somewhat unexpected, given the couple’s fairly recent commentary about finding it difficult to “quit” the home.
“We keep coming back here because the kids are very happy,” Alec revealed in an August 2025 interview with The New York Times. “They love it here. When I go up to the kids and go, ‘Want to sell the house?’, they go crazy.”
The full timeline of Alec and Hilaria Baldwin's Hamptons home listings
Via MLS records
MARCH 1996: Alec buys the house for $1.75 million
SEPTEMBER 2022: Alec and Hilaria list the home for $29 million
JANUARY 2023: Asking price is lowered to $24.9 million
FEBRUARY 2023: Listing is taken down
MARCH 2023: The Baldwins relist the home for $22.5 million
SEPTEMBER 2023: Second listing is taken down
JANUARY 2024: Alec and Hilaria put the property back on the market for $18.99 million
JANUARY 2024: Alec appears in YouTube video promoting the home
JULY 2024: Third listing is taken down
AUGUST 2025: Couple tell The New York Times they have U-turned on selling the house
DECEMBER 2025: They list the property for a fourth time, with an asking price of $21 million
JANUARY 2026: Asking price is lowered to $19.99 million
MARCH 2026: Hilaria posts an Instagram video promoting the home
JUNE 2026: Asking price is lowered to $18.99 million
JULY 2026: Fourth listing is taken down
The Baldwins have previously received an offer on the home, shortly after listing it in January 2024, but ultimately backed out of their decision to sell.
Experts have weighed in on the scenario, with listing agent Jenny Lenz, managing director of Dolly Lenz Real Estate, telling Realtor.com® the location is one of the home’s “challenges,” as it is “not considered prime for most buyers.”
“While Amagansett is trendy and idyllic, this property is north of the highway and off the beaten path, yet it’s priced as if it’s on a prime street in East Hampton or Southampton,” Lenz shared in 2024. At that time, the property was listed for the same price it currently sits at.
Lenz also maintained that the house would require a series of updates, calling it, “quite dated for the current market.”
“Buyers in this area are looking for more modern styles and either new construction or recently renovated homes,” she said.
Although the current listing does not speak to any updates the celebrity couple may have made in an attempt to move it, it does call out the contrast between the “refined finishes” and “modern comforts,” such as the chef kitchen and “welcoming living room.”
The location is positioned as a “compelling” setting where “protected farmland, equestrian trails, and world-renowned ocean beaches come together in harmony.”
“This estate offers an unparalleled sense of privacy and serenity just moments from Atlantic Avenue Beach, Indian Wells Beach, and the boutiques and restaurants of Amagansett Village,” the newest listing continues.
The listing also offers a fresh look at the home, showcasing new photography in dreamy evening light. An exterior image of the gunite pool and a sizable playset gives a peek at life for Alec and Hilaria and the seven children they have together; Carmen Gabriela, 13, Rafael Thomas, 11, Leonardo Angel Charles, 9, Romeo Alejandro David, 8, Eduardo Pao Lucas, 5, Maria Lucia Victoria, 5, and Ilaria Catalina Irena, 3.
A graphic included in the listing hints at possibility for potential buyers of the Amagansett estate, suggesting where a “proposed tennis court” could sit, as well as where a private vineyard, equestrian stable, or organic garden could be added.